May 23, 2018

Aged Chocolate: How & Why

By Jerry Toth

Aged chocolate is a new phenomenon that To'ak has been pioneering since 2013. The process is grounded in the science of flavor extraction, and draws heavily from long-standing practices in both the wine and whisky traditions. Here's a look at why we do it and how it works.

The Whisky Precedent

It is estimated that up to 80% of the aroma and flavor of a well-aged spirit, such as whisky, is derived from the barrel itself. Hence the supreme importance of barrel selection and aging conditions for whisky, cognac, tequila and pretty much anything else with an age statement on the bottle.

Oils and other chemical compounds within the wood play a key role in this process. Lignin most notably imparts vanilla notes, and can also contribute floral and spicy aromas. Lactones lend a buttery, coconut character. Hemicellulose offers a gamut of extractable aroma compounds ranging from nutty and caramel to sweet and malt.

"Chocolate has an interesting advantage in extracting flavor and aroma from the wood: namely, the absorptive oils that are naturally present in cacao."

When whisky is stored in an oak barrel, it extracts these chemical compounds from the wood and draws them into the whisky, which imparts flavor and color. When aging chocolate in wood barrels, a similar process unfolds. Usually (but not always) we insert chocolate into barrels and other wood containers when the chocolate is in solid form. Even in solid form, chocolate has an interesting advantage in extracting flavor and aroma from the wood: namely, the absorptive oils that are naturally present in cacao.

Barrel Aging Applied to Chocolate

Cacao beans are roughly 50% fat. If you press a cacao bean with a great deal of strength, you can actually extract this fat, which is referred to as “cacao butter.” Cacao butter is used as an additive to some chocolates and also as a skin care product, among other uses. At To’ak, we usually don’t add extra cacao butter to our chocolate. But the cacao butter that is already naturally present in our chocolate is put to work during the aging process.

"One of the interesting qualities of cacao butter is its remarkable ability to absorb other aromas."

One of the interesting qualities of cacao butter is its remarkable ability to absorb other aromas. Anyone who has purchased a bar of To’ak online is most likely familiar with the storage instructions we offer to each of our customers. In addition to not storing your dark chocolate in a freezer, we also remind people to protect their chocolate from other strong odors.

If you want to experiment with this phenomenon at home, try storing an open bar of chocolate in the vicinity of a sliced onion. Within a very short time, the aroma of the onion will be impregnated in the chocolate. (Please don’t use To’ak Chocolate for this experiment).

The inverse of this experiment is to store dark chocolate with pleasing aromas. This is the basis of our aging program. We age chocolate inside specialty casks (ex-cognac, ex-whisky, ex-port, etc) as well as inside Ecuadorian wood containers that we’ve built ourselves, in some cases for periods as long as four or five years.

We also produced aged dark chocolate with certain highly aromatic substances, such as Cambodian Kampot pepper, Ecuadorian Palo Santo wood, among several other experiments that we are not yet ready to announce. In each case, the fat content of the chocolate (i.e., the cacao butter) extracts these pleasing aromas from the aging vessel or aromatic medium, and the flavor of the chocolate is accordingly transformed.

"The value of this approach, as opposed to merely adding flavors at the point of production, is the subtlety and elegance of the aromas that are achieved."

The Element of Time

In some cases, aging chocolate takes many years—for example, our Ecuadorian wood-aged editions require long-term aging—up to six years so far. In other cases, a positive transformation is evident within one year—for example, our cognac edition—but the aroma continues to slowly improve over the course of many more years.

The value of this approach, as opposed to merely adding flavors at the point of production, is the subtlety and elegance of the aromas that are achieved. Over time, the flavor of the chocolate naturally evolves on its own through processes such as oxidation. Flavor extraction from barrels and other vessels adds another layer of complexity, which also evolves over time.

Doesn't Chocolate Spoil After Several Years?

Milk chocolate does spoil, because of the milk, but dark chocolate does not. The abundant tannins and polyphenols in cacao serve as a natural preservative. This study found that 80-year-old cocoa powder and 116-year-old cacao beans were still viable and "still show very high levels of antioxidant activity and flavan-3-ol content."

Many dark chocolate products have a "best by" date range of two years, but this is an entirely arbitrary number that isn't backed by any research. What is important, while storing or aging chocolate, is to keep it at a cool, consistent temperature and protected from direct sunlight.

We age our chocolate in the perpetually cool climes of the Andean city of Quito, Ecuador. The indoor temperature naturally hovers around 20° C (68° F), give or take one degree celsius, pretty much every minute of every day. 

A New Frontier

There is no precedent for this. To’ak is the first chocolate maker to deeply explore aged chocolate, so we are learning as we go. In the process, we believe we are building a new system for the production of chocolate and the crafting of flavor and aroma—one which is based on the science of wine and whisky aging, and is implemented through the work of time. 

To'ak's Aged Chocolate Experiments

Barrels & Casks

  • French Oak, ex-Cognac (private bottling)*
  • American Oak, ex-Scotch Whisky (Laphroaig)*
  • American Oak, ex-Tequila (Don Julio)*
  • American Oak, ex-Bourbon (Woodford Reserve)*
  • Spanish Oak, ex-Pedro Ximenez Sherry
  • Spanish Oak, ex-Port
  • French Oak, ex-Sauternes
  • American Oak, Ecuadorian Rum (Canuto)

Ecuadorian Wood

  • Spanish Elm*
  • Andean Alder*
  • Coastal Ecuadorian Mahogany
  • Olivo
  • Coastal Ecuadorian Cedar
  • Santos Mahogany
  • Palo Santo*

Other Aging Media

  • Kampot Pepper*
  • Pu'er Tea
  • Galapagos Sea Salt
  • Madagascar Vanilla Bean
  • Glass
  • Ceramic 

*Already launched as a commercial edition. 

Current Offerings

You can check out our current offerings of aged chocolate here


Related Posts

May 20, 2022

How To Train Your Palate Like a Professional Chocolate Taster

Ever wanted to know what goes into being a professional chocolate taster? International chocolate judge Sharon Terenzi shares five tips on how to train your palate.
Read More

By Sharon Terenzi

April 05, 2022

Using Cacao to Reverse Deforestation

We're using cacao-based agroforestry to help restore forest in coastal Ecuador. Learn how we and our conservation partners have been putting this regenerative cultivation method into practice, including the challenges we've faced and our hopes for the future.
Read More

By Jerry Toth

April 05, 2022

What is Regenerative Cacao?

Cacao trees, able to thrive in the understory of the tropical forest, provide the perfect opportunity for tropical forest restoration (or regeneration) when planted in combination with a diverse array of other trees.
Read More

By Jerry Toth